An affiliate of Martine Law, serving Texas, Minnesota, North Carolina and New Jersey. In Texas, legal services are provided by Texas Criminal Defense Attorneys PLLC, 325 N St. Paul Street, Suite 3129, Dallas, TX 75201.
Fatal Accidents and Criminal Negligence in Texas
When can a fatal accident lead to criminally negligent homicide in Texas? Understand the gross-deviation requirement and evidence questions.
In short: A fatal accident does not automatically establish criminally negligent homicide. The State must prove criminal negligence and causation, including a failure to perceive the required risk that constitutes a gross deviation from ordinary care under the circumstances. The consequence alone is not the mental state.
Explore this page 9 sections
Is any careless act criminal negligence?
No. Texas requires more than ordinary carelessness through the statutory risk and gross-deviation requirements. Counsel should identify the precise conduct alleged, rather than infer criminality from the seriousness of the loss.
Why do surrounding conditions matter?
Visibility, available information, equipment condition and the sequence of events may affect what risk should have been perceived. The review should use contemporaneous evidence, not reconstruct the person’s knowledge from information learned only afterward.
What should a defense consultation cover?
Bring the charging documents and identify relevant records or physical evidence. Explain what you personally know and what is uncertain. Counsel can assess the required risk, the alleged deviation and the causal chain separately instead of treating the case as one undifferentiated accident.
A practical example and questions for counsel
Hypothetical example: Suppose a fatal incident follows a momentary lapse during an otherwise ordinary activity. The lapse must be described precisely before it can be compared with the criminal-negligence standard. What risk existed, what information was available and why does the State characterize the departure from ordinary care as gross? These are evidence questions, not answers supplied by the tragic result. Counsel should also ask whether the prosecution’s account omits a condition that changes the risk analysis. A complete scene record can be more useful than a broad argument about whether the accused is generally careful.
How this fits Texas law
Criminally negligent homicide under section 19.05 is a state jail felony. Section 6.03 distinguishes failure to perceive a substantial, unjustifiable risk from conscious disregard of that risk. The failure must meet the statutory gross-deviation standard. A civil negligence allegation and criminal homicide charge are not the same legal determination.
How do I get started?
The first consultation is free. It is with a Director of Client Engagement, not an attorney. Clients who hire us work with an attorney. Call (214) 239-2013. Phones are answered 24/7, with AI covering when no staff is free.
Last updated October 2026
Common questions
Is any careless act criminal negligence?
No.
Why do surrounding conditions matter?
Visibility, available information, equipment condition and the sequence of events may affect what risk should have been perceived.
What should a defense consultation cover?
Bring the charging documents and identify relevant records or physical evidence.
Protecting Good People During Hard Times
Do not wait for your court date to get help. Call (214) 239-2013.
Phones are answered 24/7, with AI covering when no staff is free.
This page provides general information about Texas law. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.